[The Spike]

its so tough so i dont kno wut to do

[sportswizofthefuture]

dude if ur getting reyes, accept as fast as possible before he takes the trade back, phillips was a one year wonder and granderson gives you sb's. you never get any of those from reyes. lol. dude you trade ur life for reyes

[Some freako]

No way!!!!! Think about it, philips and granderson play for the tigers and philies, there is no way they will be benched, but the mets and the rockies have lots of talent waiting to get off the bench.

[sccrdd483]

It depends on your whole lineup. It's really hard to say without more details. But based only on what I know, I wouldn't make that trade.

[twisterr]

YES YES YES YES!!!! You are getting Reyes, drop everything and accept that trade!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Matt P]

YESReyes is going to steal 70 plus bases this year and Hawpe is a good hitter with pop in his batDo it before the other manager doesnt want to do it anymore

[baseballchamp321]

It is definitely a tough decision, and it could of been a little easier for us if you would of told us your team. Who would your backup 2b be?If you have a good backup 2b, I would make the deal. Hawpe plays in a hitters ballpark, and has been improving every year. Although Granderson has done well, I would take Reyes over Phillips any day. Even if you don't have a 2b to backup, if it is a 10-12 team league or less, I'm sure you can find one on the waiver wire.If you play in a deep league with a lot of teams, or it is a keeper league, I wouldn't do it. I also wouldn't do it if you have a SS like Troy Tulowitzki, or a SS that can get it done. If you have that kind of SS, no need for Reyes. If you are in a keeper league, I would rather the Phillips and Granderson side.Not a bad trade, but it depends on your team. Good Luck